And I say that as someone who was taught how to bake bread by a master of the art – my grandmother, Marie. She made her family’s bread for decades. She taught me her method, which starts with the water leftover from boiling potatoes. I’ve attempted to make it several times from my girlhood notes, and it’s just not…the same. Fifty years later I’m still spoiled. Plus it takes more time and attention than I want to give.
It also uses a variety of skills to pull the whole thing off. So when I saw “no-knead” bread shared I thought, well, hmmm, that would be easier. I checked out the recipe. No way, I thought. It can’t be that simple and still produce actual bread.
King Arthur Flour’s No-Knead Peasant Bread Recipe
But it is and it does! This recipe, courtesy of the fine people at King Arthur Flour, is easy. Short ingredient list, and not very many tools. This is the recipe to get anyone started baking bread.
It’s quick, as time is measured in bread baking. Two and a half hours later, you’re taking hot bread out of the oven. And it stirs together easily by hand, so there’s no hauling out a mixer even.
It takes out one of the steps, kneading. That means no flour all over the counter.
Plus I’ve developed some tips and tricks to make it even better. I’m sharing them for your sake, sure, not because my memory sans estrogen sucks. (That’s also why I immortalized the recipe and steps for chocolate nut candy made in the crock pot.)
Go to the Source – the Experts
I’m not going to repeat their recipe. Because I think it’s important to follow their instructions, step by step, the first time. It’s described well, even if you’ve never baked bread before. Let the experts take you through it. Read it all the way through, assemble ingredients, and go for it!
- The only missing detail is that “lukewarm water” isn’t very specific. You want the water between 105 and 115 degrees Fahrenheit. It should feel noticeably warm against the back of your hand. Hot, but easily tolerated. But not so hot your skin turns red.
- You can easily make the recipe vegan by using vegetarian cooking spray or olive oil instead of butter to grease the baking dish.
- Secret bonus: There’s no fat in the dough, so clean up of the mixing bowl is quick and easy with hot water and a bit of dish soap.
So give it a try. The next time you want to make it – and you will – hop back here and have a read through my tweaks, variations, and general tips I’ve discovered along the way.
You can do this! I promise! Once you’ve taken your own fresh bread out of the oven there’s no looking back. (After that, try the best oatmeal cookies ever because you are a baking badass.)
Making the Dough
- Make sure your yeast is fresh. One way to be sure without wasting any of the precious stuff is to stir the yeast into the lukewarm water instead of the dry mixture. You should see bubbles forming right away. Then pour the water quickly into the dry ingredients and start stirring.
- I prefer mixing the dough in an ordinary old stainless steel bowl that’s wider than it is tall. The 4 cups of flour fills it about 1/3 (see picture). The dough pulls away from its sides easily, and if it’s chilly in the house, I can heat the oven for 90 seconds, turn it off, and put the bowl in there to rise. Plus it spins like a top on the counter when deflating the first rise dough as instructed.
- This is a no-knead recipe, but after the mixture forms its sticky, soft ball, I will continue working the dough in the bowl (press down, circle with spatula, turn over, repeat) for about a minute to work up some of the gluten that kneading would bring to the party. I have no idea if it makes a difference but it seems like something my grandmother would do.
First Rise, Plus Weather Impact
- Yeast is greatly affected by the temperature of the place where it will rise. In the winter when the house is 65-70 degrees, I’ve found I need to slightly heat the oven (turn on long enough to be 80-90 degrees at most) and rise it in there. In summer, any warmish place not in direct sunlight will do. In winter, it’s usually the full 90 minutes for the dough to double in size. In summer, it can be as little as 60 minutes just sitting on the counter.
- Use plastic wrap, not a tea towel, to cover the dough while rising. This dough is STICKY and in my bowl it always rises just above the top. The dough will slide right off plastic wrap, but cling like a mess to cloth.
- After you’ve used the two forks to deflate the dough to get ready for the second rise, you can scrape off any that still clings to the sides of the bowl and plop it on top of the dough ball.
Second Rise in the Baking Dish
- Dough and baking dish can be heavy and the dish can be full to the top. Use an oven mitt on both hands and always lift it with both hands.
- Be extra liberal with the lube for the baking dish. Get it all the way to the rim. The fat not only makes it easier to remove, it reacts with the dough to create a crispy texture on the sides and bottom.
- My preferred pan lube is butter-flavored cooking spray. You don’t get a lot of taste, but you do get a lot of aroma and color. I also really like olive oil spray.
- I have a salt tooth, and I like sprinkling a quarter- to half-teaspoon of kosher salt on the baking dish after I’ve sprayed it, before the dough goes in for the second rise.
- My preferred baking method is as one single large loaf, though I’ve been meaning to try separating it into two smaller loaves so I can do one plain and one with herbs. I use a round stoneware baking dish about 9 inches across and 3 inches deep. As you saw at the King Arthur site, they use a much taller, narrower Pyrex baking dish.
- Just before I put it in the oven, I lightly spray the top with more cooking spray. It puts a little more crunch in the crust. Butter-flavored spray really brings out a deep golden color.
- The temperature change during baking is really important, so stay close. If you leave the kitchen, take the timer with you. Use your phone, set it to ring loudly.
- This is a damp bread when done, so err on the side of cooking a few minutes too long versus a few minutes too short. The color you want is a deep golden brown (see picture of loaf that could have used another 3-5 minutes).
- After you’ve set it on a surface to cool, thump it with a fingertip and listen to the hollow sound. It takes experience, but the less muddy or wet the sound is, the more done the loaf is. Also, if you have onlookers, thumping it will seem properly badass.
- I generally don’t even try to tip the loaf out of the baking dish until it’s been out of the oven for 15 minutes.
- If the loaf won’t release and pop out, it means you possibly could have used more lube. *ahem* Leave it for a while so it contracts and that might break its contact with the dish. If it’s still stubborn use an ordinary table knife between the pan and the loaf all the way around the sides and gently rock it to see if the place that’s sticking will crack without further violence.
Last resort, let it cool completely, then turn the dish fully upside down, grip it firmly, and start shaking. Trust me, even if at this point it tears, it’s still perfectly edible.
- As tempting as fresh, hot bread is, until the loaf has cooled down a bit, it’s really soft, so hard to cut without also crushing. Give it 30-45 minutes at least. I’ll admit the very first time I made it I burned my fingertips trying to cut a slice for, uh, quality control purposes.
- Setting it on a cooling rack helps the bottom stay crisp. You don’t want a soggy bottom! (#GBBO #MaryBerry rock!)
The Herb Variation
The texture of the bread is coarse with large bubbles, making it really excellent toasted the next day. It handles jam, butter, olive tapenade, smashed avocado, you name it. It’s also great as a mopping up bread with soups and gravies.
If I want to be sure to have the flexibility to enjoy it with both sweet and savories, I make the recipe as stated. Sometimes, though, I really want a savory version with herbs. I have a delicious salt-free herb blend (summer savory, thyme, sage, bit of rosemary etc.) with a touch of black pepper that is perfection. Herbs de Provence or an Italian blend – or a “Mrs. Dash” type salt free blend – would be delicious too. Stick with salt-free to avoid giving the yeast more salt during the rise.
The herbed version cries out for tapenade or dunking in tomato soup. Or to be smeared with garlic butter and sprinkled with Parm.
- For herbed bread add two teaspoons of the dried herbs to the dough during the original mixing stage.
- When lubing the baking dish I sprinkle the dish with some kosher salt and some herbs.
- When I spray the top of the loaf just before putting it in the oven, I also dust with a little more herb, making for an attractive top.
As I said above, one of these times I’ll split the dough in two as instructed, move half to a loaf pan, then add a teaspoon of herbs to the remaining dough and give it a quick stir to incorporate. Best of both worlds. I’m also tempted to dust the herbed loaf pan with grated Parmesan cheese and just see what happens.
I’ve made the bread enough times now that I think I could also bake it in a 13×9 rectangular pan and top with kosher salt, rosemary and drizzled olive oil. It would bake for less time but the result ought to be great and it could be sliced and eaten sooner, like to accompany a pasta dinner.
See the King Arthur nutrition info for all the deets. IF you can slice it into 20 servings, it’s 90 calories a slice. That’s a big IF, though. We fall on it like ravening wolves. When my son was visiting and we made it together, it didn’t last long enough to count anything.
Other Recipes I Love
This is not a recipe blog, and I’m not trying to monetize your eyeballs. I only do a recipe when I really, and I mean REALLY, love the result. Check out my Cheery Cherry Oatmeal and Dark Chocolate Cookies. They’re worth it.